Israel protests Nazi cartoon
Egyptian caricature published by ruling party’s newspaper features swastika-bearing flag
Reuters
The Israeli embassy has sent a complaint to the newspaper of Egypt’s ruling party about a cartoon that linked Israel and Nazis, an unusual step from a mission that tends to ignore its Egyptian media critics.
Al-Watani al-Youm (the National Today) published a cartoon on June 15 showing an aid ship apparently bound for Gaza being grabbed by an octopus carrying an Israeli flag with a Nazi swastika in place of the Star of David symbol.
The weekly is the mouthpiece of President Hosni Mubarak’s National Democratic Party.
“The Israeli Embassy chose to comment on this caricature specifically because of the comparison between Israel and Nazism,” spokeswoman Shani Cooper-Zubida told Reuters.
“There are a lot of anti-Semitic comments and caricatures in the Egyptian media that we prefer not to comment on. This one didn’t present legitimate opposition to Israeli policy, but defamation,” she said in an e-mailed response.
“Using the Nazi swastika symbol in the heart of the cartoon, and even the idea of using it, is an insult to humanity and is tantamount to an anti-Semitic statement,” said the letter sent to the newspaper and that was passed to Reuters by the embassy.
Editor Mohamed el-Alfy defended his newspapers position in an editorial saying it was a matter of freedom of expression.
~~~~~
Israeli mission complains over Egypt press cartoon
CAIRO (Reuters) – The Israeli embassy has sent a complaint to the newspaper of Egypt’s ruling party about a cartoon that linked Israel and Nazis, an unusual step from a mission that tends to ignore its Egyptian media critics.
Al-Watani al-Youm (the National Today) published a cartoon on June 15 showing an aid ship apparently bound for Gaza being grabbed by an octopus carrying an Israeli flag with a Nazi swastika in place of the Star of David symbol.
The weekly is the mouthpiece of President Hosni Mubarak’s National Democratic Party.
“The Israeli Embassy chose to comment on this caricature specifically because of the comparison between Israel and Nazism,” spokeswoman Shani Cooper-Zubida told Reuters.
“There are a lot of anti-Semitic comments and caricatures in the Egyptian media that we prefer not to comment on. This one didn’t present legitimate opposition to Israeli policy, but defamation,” she said in an emailed response.
The cartoonist, Carlos Latuff, a Brazilian, said in an email to Reuters: “The Israeli ambassador could show the same interest, that he shows for my cartoons, for the lives of the activists lost in the Freedom flotilla.”
“Allegations of anti-Semitism are a well-known strategy of the Israeli government and its supporters in order to neutralise any criticism against the Israeli apartheid. These malicious allegations will not prevent me keeping on making my cartoons on behalf of the brave Palestinian people,” he added.
Egypt in 1979 became the first Arab state to sign a peace treaty with Israel, but ties have often been chilly. The storming of a Gaza aid flotilla in May by Israeli forces in which nine activists died drew Egyptian and world criticism.
The flotilla had sought to break an Israeli blockade of Gaza. Egypt, the only Arab state to border Gaza, had been criticised by the Arab public for also imposing restrictions on border crossings. Those restrictions have now been partially lifted.
“Using the Nazi swastika symbol in the heart of the cartoon, and even the idea of using it, is an insult to humanity and is tantamount to an anti-Semitic statement,” said the letter sent to the newspaper and passed to Reuters by the embassy.
Editor Mohammad el-Alfy defended his newspaper’s position in an editorial, saying it was a matter of freedom of expression.
Egypt’s president and other officials hold frequent meetings with top Israelis, but the government is often critical of Israeli policies.
Egyptian media and the public are more vocal critics, particularly over Israel’s dealings with Palestinians. The flotilla raid drew critical articles in Egypt’s press.
(Reporting by Yasmine Saleh, editing by Edmund Blair and Peter Graff)

Tweets that mention ISRAEL UPSET AT ITS NEW NAZI IMAGE « Desertpeace -- Topsy.com said,
June 28, 2010 at 23:06
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Michael Rivero, d and Ambrosius Macrobius, xXKelly82Xx. xXKelly82Xx said: ISRAEL UPSET AT ITS NEW NAZI IMAGE: Yesterday I posted a piece which made reference to Israel’s F… http://bit.ly/9IJ6II #flotilla #israel [...]
JonnyX said,
June 28, 2010 at 23:07
I’m a member of Humanity, and I don’t feel the least bit insulted! As to the cartoon being anti-semetic, well of course it is! Everything is anti-semetic! Critcism of Israel is anti-semetism, humor at the expense of Israel is anti-semetism, semetism is anti-semetism, grilled-cheese sndwiches are anti-semetism! It’s all anti-semetism! The words simply have lost any meaning they may have had through over-use, with the result that my grilled-cheese snadwich now tastes like intolerance. (Apologies for paraphrasing)
B. Benhamid said,
June 28, 2010 at 23:22
The image of the Freedom Flotilla and the giant octopus speaks louder than words and is exactly what this rogue nation is all about.
Good work Brother Carlos Latuff, you are as always spot on.
Sandra said,
June 29, 2010 at 01:39
GREAT CARTOON!!! For now on, that’s the way we should depict the israeli flag: two blue lines w/a swastika in the center. That says it all!
morris said,
June 29, 2010 at 02:31
Why Israel does not apologise for Mavi Massacre 1:41
Israel Shamir
Martin said,
June 29, 2010 at 09:47
Israel cry me a river!
The anawer is easy: If being labelled as a nazi is offensive, then stop acting like one.
My best wishes to Gush Shalom and all who work for a just pece from with Israel, including you desert Peace.
Shalom.
Martin of the pink triangle
Al said,
June 29, 2010 at 12:28
JohnnyX: Antisemitism hasn’t lost its meaning, it’s just that the meaning has changed.
It used to refer to those who hate Jews. Now it refers to those who Jews hate.
Jay NY NY said,
June 29, 2010 at 15:54
LOLLOLOL….why would they cry over a pics. Didn’t they send out a spoof of their terrorist international privating! That is one the best pics I’ve seen in a while to describe zio-nazi behavior.
Jay@ http://www.whitemaninablackmansbody.com/ News Blog
Sanders said,
June 29, 2010 at 17:11
That flag in the cartoon is perfect. Israel’s crimes are well documented and deplorable.
But this sort of criticism, as warranted as it might be, won’t dissuade Irsraeli Zionists from their mission – to replace Muslim homogeny in the area.
That will take a very long time, so expect this to go on and on, and for the “war on terror” to continue. The big bankers want to destroy Islam, a religion which prevents them from charging interest (usury) in those countries and thus controlling those economies.
pandora said,
June 30, 2010 at 14:17
[video:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wk8GJwNM18U%5D
pandora said,
June 30, 2010 at 14:18
Oops…sorry. I thought I had imbedded this youtube video:
Zionism and Nazis *Ominous Parallels*